Atlanta downtown skyline
Newsweek Leaders in Showcase Personal Injury
Super Lawyers
Martindale-Hubbell
AVVO
the National Trial Lawyers
GeorgiaTrend

The “Equal Knowledge Rule” in Slip and Fall Cases

Slip and fall cases can be among the most challenging personal injury cases handled by attorneys. This is due to the fact that the owner of the property is not responsible for the injury simply because it occurred. Rather, the person who suffered the personal injury must demonstrate that the property owner had superior knowledge regarding the hazard which caused the fall.

If the property owner had only “Equal Knowledge” about the hazard, then the person injured due to the slip and fall cannot recover. Due to this requirement, slip and fall cases are often litigated, and motions for summary judgment are usually filed during the litigation. Because slip and fall cases are so challenging, it is extremely important that the person who is injured hire an attorney who regularly handles premise liability claims. An understanding of the equal knowledge rule will help the injury victim better understand why these cases are so challenging.

Knowledge of the Hazardous Condition

If a person enters a business, observes water on the floor and then falls on the water, that individual can generally not recover due to their slip and fall. Because the injured person became aware of the water before they fell, they are deemed to have the same (equal) knowledge of the hazard as the business owner. Once a person has knowledge of the hazard on the floor, they are considered to be in the same position as the owner. There are certain exceptions to this rule when the hazards are located where the person lives and cannot be avoided.

However, in most cases the injured person’s knowledge of the hazard prohibits their right to recover any damages. The more challenging aspect of the slip and fall case is when a plaintiff and business owner both claim to have had no knowledge whatsoever of the hazard. In this circumstance, courts apply the “equal knowledge" rule to deny relief to the injured individual. Accordingly, it is extremely important for the attorney handling the slip and fall case to have a thorough understanding of “constructive knowledge,” because this legal theory is one way to rebut the property owner’s defense.

Constructive Knowledge in Slip and Fall Legal Claims

Constructive knowledge is based upon the principle that the owner of the property has a duty to thoroughly inspect their premises to discover and correct hazards. Once those hazards are discovered, they must be removed by the owner of the property. Accordingly, central to the litigation of slip and fall matters is a determination whether or not the owner of the property had in place proper inspection procedures such that he or she should have discovered the hazard. If proper inspection procedures were in place and followed, and the hazard was not discovered, then the owner the property may not be held liable. However, in circumstances where the owner of the property does not have proper inspection procedures in place, then he or she is presumed to have “constructive knowledge" of the hazard and can be held responsible even though the owner did not actually know the hazard was present.

One method of demonstrating that an owner has constructive knowledge of a hazard is to show that they did not have a regular routine of inspecting the premises. Generally, requests are made during litigation for copies of the owner’s inspection procedures, as well as a log which indicates when these inspections were actually performed. Simply having inspection procedures in place will not allow the property owner to avoid responsibility in a slip and fall case if the inspection procedures were not followed. Very often, a business owner during litigation will claim to have the proper procedures in place and will claim that the procedures were followed, but depositions of the employees who were present that day will often allow the attorney for the person injured in the slip and fall to demonstrate that the procedures were not actually implemented.

The business owner’s “constructive knowledge” of the hazard is very often the central focus of motions for summary judgment and the litigation in general. Accordingly, anyone who has been injured by a slip and fall should always seek to retain an attorney who is extremely knowledgeable about and has regularly litigated slip and fall claims. If you or a loved one has been injured in a slip and fall, please contact Katz Wright Fleming Dodson & Mildenhall LLC at (404) 460-0101 for a free consultation and evaluation of your claim.

Client Reviews
★★★★★
I was in a head-on collision last year that put me in a wheelchair with a fractured femur. I needed an attorney and my cousin recommended this firm because he had used Briant Mildenhall for his accident. I was glad I called Briant because he always did what he said he would do and kept me informed. We settled with the insurance company and I'm happy with the result. If someone I know needs an attorney, I will tell them to call Briant because he will get the job done. Michael G.
★★★★★
After a head–on collision I had extremely serious injuries to my back and neck, and some internal injuries. I was airlifted to the hospital and started a huge amount of medical expenses accumulating. I hired a lawyer recommended by a friend but I was not satisfied. My cousin told me about this firm so I talked to Briant Mildenhall about handling the case. I was at ease from the get–go. Briant kept me informed all the way through, was always reassuring and did everything he said he would do. He helped us get the money we needed to get the treatment we needed. Briant was fantastic! Ronda W. (Car Accident)
★★★★★
I was in a car accident that was complicated from the start. I looked on the internet and called a few different lawyers but they turned me down after they heard my story. When I called this firm Lyn Dodson asked me to talk to her in person. I met with Lyn and Rob Katz and after hearing my story they were confident I had a case. They vigorously pursued my case and over time we built a trusting relationship. Lyn even took time to help me with the traffic issues and other aspects of the case. They were always on my side and talked to me about the advantages and disadvantages of my options... Robert W. (Car Accident)
★★★★★
After my car accident, I was looking for an attorney and came across the name Katz Wright Fleming Dodson & Mildenhall LLC. My intuition told me to call. I called in and Briant Mildenhall talked to me. He was very clear and honest about my options. As the case went forward, Briant and the staff at the law office always answered my questions right away. I was very confident in Briant's legal ability. He kept me informed every step of the way. I would recommend Mr. Mildenhall and the firm to anyone who needs an attorney. Antonio J. (Car Accident)
★★★★★
I would recommend the law firm of Katz Wright Fleming Dodson & Mildenhall LLC. Lyn Dodson was my attorney after my auto accident. I had confidence in her legal abilities and experience. She did a very good job for me. She was always there to answer the many questions I asked. The firm is very professional. Lyn always gave you her undivided attention. The firm, especially Lyn, worked with you like a long time friend. Joe B. (Auto Accident)
★★★★★
I am 100% satisfied. I called Rob the day after the accident. Everything he said that would happen did, every step of the way. He went beyond what we needed him to do. I would definitely use him again and recommend him to anyone who needs a lawyer. Steve H.
★★★★★
Robert Katz isn't your average personal injury lawyer. He has specialized knowledge and experience that the others don't. Timothy W. (Trucking Accident)
★★★★★
I have nothing but good and positive things to say about Rob. One of the unique things about my case was that I was involved in a bicycle accident with another biker. He took an unorthodox case between two bicycle riders and he could see the logic and liability in it. I was very happy with the result. Rodney H. (Bicycle Accident)
★★★★★
We just loved him to death. He acted like he cared about us, not just our case. He kept us posted on everything. He even called us on Sundays to update us. My case involved a rear-end collision where I had herniated disks and I had had a prior back injury. Complicated as it was, we were very happy with the outcome. Kathy H. (Car accident)
★★★★★
Throughout the course of my case, Mr. Katz kept me informed about its status, returned my telephone calls and was very attentive to my needs and concerns. Simply put, he cared not just about my case, but about me. Joseph B.
★★★★★
I was, and still am, extremely satisfied with Rob's work and with the outcome of my case. Rob strives to be there for his clients, and I was no exception...I would happily recommend Rob to anyone who is seeking legal assistance after suffering a severe injury. Joey E.
Contact Us

1 Free Consultation

2 No Obligation

3 150 Years Combined Experience

Complete the contact form or call us at (888) 426-2100 to schedule your free consultation.

I have read the disclaimer. (Required)
Please note that sending us a message via our website or any other online property does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and any lawyer at Katz Wright Fleming Dodson & Mildenhall LLC.
Captcha Image